Do Not Obey in Advance

A week and a half in, I’m terribly sad for the world. It shouldn’t be like this.

Last month, I wrote about meat-axing my news consumption following the disastrous results of November’s presidential election. I remain broadly informed, but I’ve reduced the amount of US news I allow to capture my attention. More than I’d like makes it through, particularly in the form of headlines, but I’m doing what I can to disregard the less meaningful stupidities of Donald Trump’s presidency. I’m also avoiding writing about the monster assembled entirely from human flaws himself as much as I can. Still, it’s impossible and probably unwise to ignore this slow-motion train wreck entirely.

Last year, I read historian Timothy Snyder’s book “On Tyranny”. The brief tome contains 20 simple instructions for preserving freedom in a repressive regime, such as “Defend institutions”, “Learn from peers in other countries”, and “Contribute to good causes”. It was initially published during the first Trump presidency, and it seems even more relevant as we enter the depths of Trump’s second term.

The book has been on my mind recently because of its very first instruction: “Do not obey in advance”:

Text reading: “Do not obey in advance. - Most of the power of authoritarianism is freely given. In times like these, individuals think ahead about what a more repressive government will want, and then offer themselves without being asked. A citizen who adapts in this way is teaching power what it can do.”
[Image credit: “On Tyranny” Kindle sample]

Companies including Meta to CNN have been sickeningly quick to demonstrate their fealty to Trump. This preemptive obedience is precisely what Snyder warns against. I hope world and business leaders can learn this lesson before it’s too late for all of us.