Up in Canada, a junior high art teacher is in trouble for selling student art without their consent. Obviously, that’s wrong, and he shouldn’t have done it. This, however, seems more than a little ridiculous:
The parents of 10 young students at Westwood Junior High School in Saint-Lazare, Que., an off-island suburb west of Montreal, filed the lawsuit for $1.575 million, or $155,000 per plaintiff plus punitive damages…for alleged copyright infringement.
Thought it’s a steal compared to what Basquiat’s “Untitled” will run you, that’s rather a lot of money for some not very good art:
Joel DeBellefeuille, another parent represented in the lawsuit, says while the amount of money sought might seem outrageous, it represents the scale of intellectual property infringement that took place.
“We requested $5,000 per artwork that was infringed,” he said, saying there were 31 pieces of plagiarized merchandise per student.
I doubt very much that these ridiculous numbers represent the “scale of IP infringement” at all. In fact, I suspect that not a single one of these items actually sold. The “31 pieces of plagiarized merchandise” were apparently available on pixels.com, which is a print-on-demand service offering items like mugs and yoga mats. Unless something actually sold, the “pieces” never actually existed.
In addition to the money, the lawsuit states the group of parents is asking for a written apology from Perron, the removal of the students’ artwork from all websites and a report of any sales made in connection with the plagiarized works.
All of that is fair. The money being sought here, however, is nonsense.